I may just be the type of homeschooler that needs more direction and guidance in order to teach my children all of the concepts that should be covered. I did not feel that Tapestry of Grace provided that for me.
I even tried the new redesigned version and the new digital version. I downloaded the book list for the Year 2 version, and it was the same for me- about half of the books are not available at the library and really hard to get for a reasonable price.
It was frustrating and we gave up to look for other options.